Herd Mentality on Dalal Street: Emotional Investing & Bubbles

Dalal Street – the heart of India’s stock markets – can sometimes feel like a stampede. When a few investors rush into a stock, others often follow without asking why. This herd mentality can create dangerous market bubbles. In other words, when emotions rule, prices can soar far beyond true value, and eventually crash back down. For many investors, understanding this crowd psychology is the first step to protecting their money.

On any given day, you might see headlines about “limit up” or “unprecedented rally”. If you buy because everyone else is buying, that’s herd mentality in action. In fact, analysts warn that herding can “lead to asset bubbles” and even market crashes. This article explores the dark psychology behind following the crowd on Dalal Street – from emotional investing to bubble formation – and offers tips to stay rational and safe.

What is Herd Mentality?

Herd mentality (sometimes called herd behavior or mob mentality) is simply following the crowd. Think of investors like a flock of sheep: when one sheep moves, the others follow, even if there’s no clear reason. In the stock market, this means buying or selling just because others are doing it. As experts explain, humans naturally mimic others in uncertain situations. Many investors see their friends or influencers buying a stock, so they jump in too – without doing proper research.

One finance article defines this bias as an investor’s “tendency to copy what others are doing”. This often happens on emotion, not logic. For example, during the dot-com bubble of 1999–2000, countless people bought tech stocks simply “because everyone else was doing so,” even when those companies had weak business models. In India, herd mentality can sweep through Dalal Street just as strongly. Whether it’s a fast-rising IPO or a stock tip from a peer, many investors pile in together. This makes it easy to miss seeing the danger signs until it’s too late.

Why We Follow the Crowd

Why do smart people sometimes blindly follow others? Psychology offers some clues:

• Fear of Missing Out (FOMO): Nobody wants to be left behind when a stock is skyrocketing. If you see your neighbor making money hand over fist, it’s tempting to jump in, even if you don’t fully understand why the rally started. That “everybody’s making money” feeling can override caution.
• Social Proof: We assume the crowd knows something we don’t. If thousands of people are buying a stock, it must be good, right? This shortcut (a type of heuristic) saves time but can be dangerous. As the Economic Times notes, herd behavior is like seeing a crowded restaurant – we think “it must be great” without really checking.
• Emotional Pressure: Imagine an old friend calls and says, “You should have bought before! That stock is flying!” You might feel pressured and guilty. Emotions like regret and greed can push us to act fast. One analyst remarked that when “too many people buy at the same time… the impact cost… takes away whatever alpha you were trying to make”. In other words, in a crowded trade, everyone drives the price up, and gains shrink.
• Confirmation Bias: Once we get a tip, we start looking only for information that confirms it. If all our online feeds light up with positive chatter, we stop questioning. The Economic Times highlights how group thinking can give investors “an illusion of being indestructible”. In a herd, dissenting opinions (and cautionary data) are often drowned out.

These factors work together. You might start with a small spark of curiosity, then social media and word-of-mouth blow it into a wildfire of action. On Dalal Street, where news and tips spread quickly, this “pack behavior” can form and grow in hours.

Emotional Investing: Fear and Greed in Play

Emotions – especially fear and greed – drive much of herd behavior. When the market is going up, greed takes hold. People feel excitement and euphoria, thinking every stock will keep rising. Indicators like the Fear & Greed Index (often cited by analysts) actually track these emotions. This index gauges whether investors are driven by fear or by greed. When greed dominates, warning signals are ignored; when fear spikes, we see panicked sell-offs.

Emotional investing means making decisions based on how we feel at the moment. For example, after a few days of big stock gains, you might feel like you must buy now or miss out. Conversely, after a sharp drop, fear can make you sell everything. This flip-flop often creates a feedback loop: the herd sells fast, prices dive, then the herd jumps back in at the lowest point, hoping for a rebound.

Even professional fund managers have warned about this. Samit Vartak of SageOne told NDTV Profit that due to easy information flows, “everyone gets bullish at the same time and money flows into those pockets very, very quickly”, boosting the herd mentality. In plain terms, modern trading apps and 24/7 news mean we all see the same information at the same time – which can cause everyone to feel and act the same way.

In our own portfolios, emotional investing often shows up as impulsive trades. You might hear about a “hot tip” and decide to buy immediately, only realizing later you hadn’t checked valuations. When dozens of investors do this together, it inflates prices beyond what a company’s earnings justify. Psychologists say this is collective rationalization: individually we might suspect something’s off, but if everyone’s doing it, we push those doubts aside.

How Herd Behavior Creates Stock Market Bubbles

What exactly is a market bubble? It’s when prices of stocks (or other assets) rise far above their real value, driven by hype and speculation. Herd mentality is a prime driver of these bubbles. As the Economic Times explains, when everyone piles into a trend, prices “soar far beyond their true value,” setting the stage for big losses when the bubble bursts.

Forbes India warns that herding underlies “some of the biggest stock and property bubbles in history”. Those include the dot-com mania (late 1990s) and even meme-stock rallies in 2021–2022. In each case, large groups of investors copied each other, often driven by fear of missing out, until valuations became unsustainable. In the context of Dalal Street, bubbles can form quickly once enough buyers fuel an upswing.

Common signs of a brewing bubble include:

• Rapid, Crazy Gains: Stocks jump 50–100% (or more) in a short time with little news to justify it.
• Ignore Fundamentals: Investors pay less attention to earnings or P/E ratios and more to “how fast it’s going up.”
• Widespread Hype: News, social media, and brokers all talk up the same stocks.
• Newbies Rush In: Suddenly, first-time investors and small traders are entering the market in huge numbers.

A recent example is the enthusiasm around certain blue-chip and new IPO stocks in India. In 2020–2021, the Sensex and Nifty more than doubled from their March 2020 lows, even as India struggled with the pandemic. BusinessToday observed that such a “quick run-up” raised concerns over rational expectations. As greed took hold, many ignored warnings and piled in – classic bubble behavior.

The consequence? Eventually, reality (company profits, global events, etc.) reasserts itself. When no new buyers show up at those sky-high prices, the bubble pops. Investors who bought late watch prices plummet. The Outlook Money newsletter points out that unchecked optimism leads to inflated valuations and inevitable bursts. For instance, stocks with very high P/E ratios (prices far above earnings) eventually fell back, causing “significant wealth erosion for investors who entered at peak valuations”. In other words, latecomers to the herd often suffer the biggest losses.

Herd Behavior on Dalal Street: Real Examples

Indian markets have their share of herd-driven frenzies. A few notable cases:

• Adani Group Stocks (2023): Despite controversies, retail investors continued to support these stocks, reflecting sentiment trumping fundamentals. One analysis notes that “Adani Group stocks exemplify” herd mentality – many backed the shares “despite controversies”. This unwavering backing helped inflate valuations until a sharp correction occurred.
• Post-COVID Rally (2020–21): After the March 2020 crash, mutual fund SIP inflows surged and new trading accounts opened in droves. By mid-2021, Sensex and Nifty had more than doubled. Many attributed this to herd behavior: with news of vaccines and stimulus, large crowds got bullish at once. BusinessToday data shows metrics like cross-sectional stock return dispersion (CSAD) fell, indicating more stocks moving together – a sign of heavy herding.
• Demonetization Spike (2016): When India announced demonetization in Nov 2016, investors panicked and sold stocks en masse, followed by a swift rally a few months later. The initial crash had little to do with company fundamentals – it was fear and uncertainty triggering a herd sell-off. Later, retail investors who missed the initial drop rushed back in, driving prices higher.
• Global Cues and Herds: Sometimes herds jump on global trends. For example, when US markets surged or crashed, Indian investors often followed the same direction, magnifying moves on Dalal Street. After the U.S. dot-com crash (2000) or the 2008 financial crisis, Indian indices fell sharply as local investors panicked in step with overseas markets.

These cases highlight that no market, not even Dalal Street, is immune to mob behavior. In each, group emotions – often amplified by media coverage – overrode cautious analysis.

The Human Psychology at Play

Herd behavior is deeply rooted in human nature. Psychologists point out that going with the crowd can feel safer. If everyone else is buying a stock, our brain thinks “they must know something.” This social proof can shut down our independent judgment. In a frenzy, you might feel irrationally greedy when things go up, and terrified when they plunge. Both emotions fuel the herd.

For example, on October 19, 1987 (global Black Monday), the Dow fell 23% in a day. Later surveys found that two-thirds of investors blamed collective psychology, not any particular news. They said the panic sell-off was driven by people following each other, not by fundamentals. The same can happen on Dalal Street: a few drops in key stocks trigger more selling by the herd, creating a cascade.

Behavioral finance studies also show that advisors and even professionals can get swept up by herd pressure. One DSIJ analysis notes that in bullish markets, investors pile into whatever everyone else is buying. In bearish markets, they sell en masse when others do. This creates a feedback loop – momentum chasing – where trends feed on themselves.

It’s also important to consider where the “herd” information comes from. Today’s investors hear tips from WhatsApp forwards, TV pundits, and friends. These sources can spread hype (or fear) quickly. As one strategist said, because “everyone gets the information at the same time…unfortunately, that probably boosts the herd mentality”. In other words, modern technology can accelerate the pack.

The Cost of Riding the Herd

Chasing the herd can be costly. Some key risks include:

• Higher Trading Costs: Frequent buying and selling in a frenzy means many transaction fees. As DSIJ explains, herd-chasing often leads to frequent trading, which can eat into profits. When everyone jumps in late, the only way to make gains is to trade rapidly – and that means commissions and taxes add up.
• Poor Timing: By the time the average investor hears about a hot tip, the stock may have already run up a lot. Jumping in late often means buying at or near the top. Then, when the herd turns or the market corrects, late buyers face the steepest losses.
• Misvalued Assets: Herds push prices far above intrinsic value. The share price becomes driven by hype, not earnings. Eventually, reality hits – maybe disappointing news or just exhaustion of buyers – and the “bubble” deflates. Those who joined late realize they paid far more than they should have.
• Emotional Stress: Being in a herd means your decisions are driven by FOMO or panic, not logic. This is mentally exhausting. You might experience huge regret during crashes (“Why didn’t I sell?”), which can lead to poor future decisions. Emotional investing tends to trap people in the wrong trades longer than they should.

For instance, as NDTV Profit reported, “being a part of the herd snatches the ease of beating the market.” When too many buy at once, even skilled fund managers find it hard to get a competitive advantage. The momentum simply carries prices away.

How to Avoid Getting Swept Up

The good news is that being aware of herd mentality can help you stay rational. Here are some practical strategies:

• Do Your Own Research: Before buying, check the fundamentals. What are the company’s earnings, growth prospects, and risks? Do you understand why the stock is rising? If you can’t explain it simply, be cautious. As one personal finance guide suggests, rely on analysis over hearsay.
• Set Long-Term Goals: Align your decisions with your goals and risk tolerance. If your plan is a 5–10 year horizon, short-term market noise (and herd moves) shouldn’t sway you. Focus on steady growth, not quick gains. Remember Warren Buffett’s wisdom: “Be fearful when others are greedy and be greedy when others are fearful.”
• Question the Consensus: Always ask “Why is everyone buying this?” or “What don’t I see?” If a trade feels too easy, scrutinize it. Don’t let crowd psychology force you into instant decisions. It often pays to be the contrarian – buying when others are pessimistic, and selling when the herd is euphoric.
• Stick to Your Strategy: Create an investment plan or checklist. For example, decide that you will only buy a stock if it meets certain valuation criteria. Use stop-loss orders or take-profit targets to enforce discipline. This way, you avoid emotional knee-jerk trades. A disciplined approach keeps you grounded when market chatter becomes loud.
• Diversify and Protect: Don’t put all your funds into a single “hot” trend. Spread investments across sectors or asset classes. This reduces the impact if one bubble bursts. Also, keep some cash on the sidelines – this lets you buy bargains after a crash, rather than having all money tied up during the run-up.
• Stay Informed but Skeptical: Follow market news, but balance it with independent analysis. Awareness is good, but uncritically following pundits or social media is risky. If possible, consult multiple sources. For example, if a reputed magazine or an expert (like [Moneycontrol] or an expert blog) raises doubts, give their view weight.
• Learn from Past Mistakes: Study history. Famous manias (like the dot-com and previous Indian bubbles) often followed the same pattern of herd excess. Realizing these parallels can make you pause when current conditions look similar.

By taking these steps, you act with the market’s reality rather than just its crowd mood. As one expert puts it, disciplined, well-researched investing is key to “navigating the complexities of the financial world”. In other words, do your homework and stay level-headed, and you’ll be less likely to fall into herd traps.

Conclusion

The stock market is a human story as much as a numbers game. On Dalal Street, as elsewhere, the crowd’s emotions – fear, greed, euphoria – can create powerful waves that lift all boats temporarily and then sink the unprepared. We’ve seen how herd mentality (or “mob psychology”) can fuel astonishing bubbles, driven by emotional investing and social influence.

Understanding these psychological forces is vital. By recognizing the signs of herd behavior and sticking to rational principles, investors can avoid being the “last in the line” when a bubble bursts. Remember that what goes up under herd influence can come down just as fast. As the Outlook newsletter cautions, unchecked optimism must be balanced with awareness of risks.

In the end, prudent Dalal Street investors learn to be leaders, not followers. They ask questions, analyze fundamentals, and trust their own judgment even when the herd roars. That way, they protect their portfolios from the pitfalls of crowd psychology. After all, in the world of investing, it often pays to be a little independent – and not just another sheep.

FAQs